Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ben Piggot's avatar

I think we have seen a bit of the same thing again with Iran

MJVD's avatar

I remember saying in January 2022 "call me when Russian forward deploys their S-400 batteries"

I figured they would not want a large number of S-400 giving off their radar emissions within range of NATO SIGINT assets. Why allow a potential adversay to analyze the radar emissions and develop more sophisticated jamming unless not forward deploying them was a worse outcome? (Giving Ukraine a more permissible air environment).

Well they did forward deploy large numbers of S-400s in mid February. And I walked it back! Despite saying that was the evidence I needed to conclude it was likely, when I was presented with the evidence I let my bias take over and discount it.

A lot of us in the west did not appropriately separate our view of the costs of war from the Russian view. How negatively we view loss of life, the opportunity costs of spending so many resources on war, and some sense of 'wars of conquest just don't happen in Europe anymore'.

All of the evidence can be there, but we saw the evidence through our own cultural lense and with our own values. We didn't assess the evidence with Russian culture and Russian values.

63 more comments...

Ready for more?